|
| 1. | | Whether it is a violation case and application is being submitted under Notification No. S.O.804(E) dated 14.03.2017 ? | No | | Details of Project: | | (a)Name of the project(s) | Grain based Distillery (2* 45 KLD) and Co-generation Power Plant (2*3MW) and IMFL/IMIL bottling (2*8000 day). | | (b)Name of the Company / Organisation | Starlight Energy Pvt. Ltd. | | (c)Registered Address | NIL | | (d)Legal Status of the Company | NIL | | (e)Joint Venture | No | |
|
| 2. | | Address for the correspondence: | | (a)Name of the Applicant | | | (b)Designation (Owner/ Partner/ CEO) | Director | | (c)Address | NIL | | (d)Pin code | 769001 | | (e)E-mail | jain_yp@yahoo.com | | (f)STD Code. | (f)Telephone No. | | | (g)Fax No. | 2600528 | | (h)Copy of documents in support of the competence/authority of the person making this application to make application on behalf of the User Agency . | Annexure-Uploaded Copy of documents in support of the competence/authority | |
|
| 3. | | Category of the Project/Activity as per Schedule of EIA Notification,2006: | | (a.I)Project/Activity | 5(g) Distilleries
| | Minor Activity | | | (b)Category | A | | (c)Proposal Number | IA/OR/IND2/69696/2014 | | (d)Master Proposal Number(Single Window) | SW/90719/2019 | | (e)EAC concerned (for category A Projects only) | Industrial Projects - 3 | | (f)Project Type | Fresh EC |
|
|
| 4. | | Location of the Project: | | (a)Plot/Survey/Khasra No. | 212,244,248,240,250,251,252,253,254,255,256,257,25 | | (b)Pincode | 769001 | | (c)Bounded Latitudes (North) | | | From | | | Degree | 19.324 | | Minutes | | | Second | | | From | | | Degree | 19.826 | | Minutes | | | Second | | | (d)Bounded Longitudes (East) | | | From | | | Degree | 82.875 | | Minutes | | | Second | | | From | | | Degree | 82.88 | | Minutes | | | Second | | | (e)Survey of India Topo Sheet No. | 65I/13 & 65 I/14 | | (f)Uploaded Topo Sheet File | Copy of Topo Sheet File | | (g)Maximum Elevation Above Means Sea Level(AMSL) | 232.2 | | (h)Uploaded (kml) File | Copy of Kml File  | | (i)Distance of Nearest HFL from the project boundary within the study area | 123.89 | | (j)Seismic Zone | 2 | |
|
| 5. | | (a)Number of States in which Project will be Executed | 1 | | (b)Main State of the project | Orissa | |
|
|
| Details of State of the project |
|---|
| S. No. | State Name | District Name | Tehsil Name | Village Name |
|---|
| NIL |
|
|
| 6. | | Details of Terms of Reference (ToR): | | (a)MoEF&CC / SEIAA File Number | MoEF File No. J-11011/298/2014 IA II (I) | | (b)Date of Apply of TOR | 16 Sep 2014 | | (c)Date of Issue of TOR / Standard ToR | 23 Jan 2015 | | (d)Previous TOR Letter | Copy of Previous TOR letter | |
|
| 7. | | Details of Public Consultation: | | (a)Whether the Project Exempted from Public Hearing? | No | | (b)Whether details of Public Hearing available? | Yes | | (c)Whether Public hearing was presided over by an officer of the rank of Additional District Magistrate or above | Yes | |
|
| 7.1. Details of Public Hearing |
|---|
|
| S. No. | Details of Advertisement | Details of Public Hearing | Venue | Location Details | No. of People Attended | Issues Raised | Designation of Presiding Officer | Other Designation of Presiding Officer |
|---|
| (1.) | | | Copy of Public Hearing : | Copy of Public Hearing | | Date : | 01 Nov 2018 | | Distance of Public Hearing Venue from the Proposed Project : | 2 |
| At gram panchayat office, palas, under Jhunagarh Block, Distt: Kalahandi | | State : | Orissa | | District : | Kalahandi | | Tehsil : | Junagarh | | Village : | gourd-sariguda |
| 41 | During Public Hearing, Issues regarding the pollution c and employment generation were raised | District Magistrate | |
|
| 8. | | Details of Project Configuration/Product: | |
|
| 8.1. Project Configuration |
|---|
| S. No. | Plant/Equipment/Facility | Configuration | Remarks |
|---|
| (1.) | captive power plant | 2*3 mw | | | (2.) | IMFL/IMIL bottling plant | 2*8000 | | | (3.) | grain based distillery | 2*45 KLD | |
|
| 8.2. Product |
|---|
| S. No. | Product/Activity (Capacity/Area) | Quantity | Unit | Other Unit | Mode of Transport / Transmission of Product | Other Mode of Transport / Transmission of Product |
|---|
| (1.) | ENA/RS/Ethyl Alcohol | 90 | Kilo Litre per Day | | Road | | | (2.) | IMFL/country liquor | 16000 | Others | cases | Road | |
|
|
| 9. | | In case of Expansion / Modernisation / One Time Capacity Expansion (only for Coal Mining) / Expansion under Clause 7(ii) / Modernisation under Clause 7(ii) / Change of Product Mix under Clause 7(ii): | | Details Not Applicable | |
|
| 9.1. | | Details of Consent to Operate | | (i)Whether Consent to operate obtained ? | NA | | (ii)Copies of all Consent to operate obtained since inception | NA | | (iii)Date of Issue | 01 Jan 2019 | | (iv)Valid Upto | 07 Jan 2019 | | (v)File No. | NA | | (vi)Application No. | NA | | (vii)Copy of Consent to operate valid as on date | Copy of Consent to Operate | |
|
|
| 10. | | Project Cost: | | (a)Total Cost of the Project at current price level (in Crores) | 92 | | (b) Funds Allocated for Environment Management (Capital) (in Crores) | 9.1 | | (c) Funds Allocated Towards CER (Corporate Environment Responsibility) (in Crores) | 0.18 | | (d) Funds Allocated for Environment Management Plan (EMP) (Recurring per Annum) (in Crores) | 04 | |
|
| 11. | | Whether project attracts the General Condition specified in the Schedule of EIA Notification ? | No |
| |
| 12. | | Whether project attract the Specific Condition specified in the Schedule of EIA Notification ? | No |
|
|
| 13. | | Raw Material / Fuel Requirement: | | (a)Proposed quantity of raw material/fuel | 00 | | (b)Existing quantity of raw material/fuel | N/A | | (c)Total quantity of raw material/fuel | 0 | |
|
| 13.1. Raw Material / Fuel Profile |
|---|
| S. No. | Raw Material / Fuel | Quantity | Unit | Other Unit | Source (incase of Import. please specify country and Name of the port from which Raw Material / Fuel is received ) | Mode of Transport | Other Mode of Transport | Distance of Source from Project Site (in Kilometres) (In case of import, distance from the port from which the raw material / fuel is received) | Type of Linkage | Other Type of Linkage | Uploaded Copy of Linkage |
|---|
| (1.) | Enzymes | 66000 | Others | kg | nearby market | Road | | 01 | Open Market | | Copy of Linkage | | (2.) | Non- Edible/ Waste Grain - Broken Rice, Sorghum, Bajra, Maize etc. | 75900 | Others | metric tonn | nearby market | Road | | 01 | Open Market | | Copy of Linkage | | (3.) | Urea | 148500 | Others | kg | nearby market | Road | | 01 | Open Market | | Copy of Linkage | | (4.) | Boiler Fuel Biomass (Rice Husk) | 116160 | Others | metric tonn | nearby market | Road | | 1 | Open Market | | Copy of Linkage | | (5.) | Anti-foam Agent | 16500 | Others | kg | nearby market | Road | | 01 | Open Market | | Copy of Linkage | | (6.) | Yeast | 66000 | Others | kg | nearby market | Road | | 01 | Open Market | | Copy of Linkage | | (7.) | Sodium hydroxide | 33000 | Others | kg | nearby market | Road | | 01 | Open Market | | Copy of Linkage |
|
|
| 14. | | Baseline Data : | | (a)Period of Base Line Data Collection | FROM 01 Jan 2015 To 31 Mar 2015 | | (b)Season | Winter | |
|
| 14.1. No. of ambient Air Quality (AAQ) monitoring locations : 06 |
|---|
| S. No. | Criteria Pollutants | Other Criteria Pollutants | Unit | Maximum Value | Minimum Value | 98 Percentile Value | Prescribed Standard |
|---|
| (1.) | PM2.5 | | Micro Gram per Meter Cube | 40.8 | 30.9 | 40.75 | 60 | | (2.) | SO2 | | Micro Gram per Meter Cube | 18.7 | 7 | 18.45 | 80 | | (3.) | NOx | | Micro Gram per Meter Cube | 26.9 | 15.2 | 26.65 | 80 | | (4.) | PM10 | | Micro Gram per Meter Cube | 78.9 | 50.3 | 78.9 | 100 |
|
| 14.2. No. of Ground Water monitoring locations : 06 |
|---|
| S. No. | Criteria Pollutants | Other Criteria Pollutants | Heavy Metal | Unit | Other Unit | Maximum Value | Minimum Value | Desirable Limit | Maximum Permissible Limit |
|---|
| (1.) | pH | | | NA | | 7.85 | 7.42 | 6.5 | 8.5 | | (2.) | Fluoride | | | mg/l | | 0.77 | 0.26 | 1.0 | 1.5 | | (3.) | Heavy Metals | | Iron | mg/l | | 0.77 | 0.26 | 1.0 | 1.5 | | (4.) | TDS | | | mg/l | | 685.12 | 370 | 500 | 2000 | | (5.) | Chlorides | | | mg/l | | 168.50 | 18.54 | 250 | 1000 | | (6.) | Total Hardness | | | mg/l | | 472.55 | 276.65 | 200 | 600 | | (7.) | TSS | | | mg/l | | 00 | 00 | 00 | 00 |
|
| 14.3. No. of Surface Water monitoring locations : 02 |
|---|
| S. No. | Criteria Pollutants | Other Criteria Pollutants | Unit | Other Unit | Maximum Value | Minimum Value | Classification of inland water body |
|---|
| (1.) | pH | | NA | | 7.92 | 7.42 | C | | (2.) | DO | | mg/l | | 5.60 | 5 | C | | (3.) | COD | | mg/l | | 39 | 36 | C | | (4.) | BOD | | mg/l | | 12.50 | 11.20 | C |
|
| 14.4. No. of Ambient Noise monitoring locations : 06 |
|---|
| S. No. | Parameter | Unit | Maximum Value | Minimum Value | Prescribed Standard |
|---|
| (1.) | Leq(Night) | A-weighted decibels(dB(A)) | 44.50 | 40.20 | 55 | | (2.) | Leq(Day) | A-weighted decibels(dB(A)) | 53.63 | 51.92 | 65 |
|
| 14.5. No. of Soil Sample Monitored locations : 06 |
|---|
| S. No. | Parameter | Unit | Other Unit | Maximum Value | Minimum Value |
|---|
| (1.) | pH | Others | NA | 7.78 | 7.34 | | (2.) | P(Phosphorus) | Kilogram per hectare | | 46.10 | 32.81 | | (3.) | K(Potassium) | Kilogram per hectare | | 258.92 | 210 | | (4.) | N(Nitrogen) | Kilogram per hectare | | 271.49 | 228.88 | | (5.) | Electric Conductivity | Millisiemens per Centimetre | | 0.521 | 0.328 |
|
|
| 14.6. | | Details of Ground Water Table: | | (a)Range of Water Table Pre-Monsoon Season (Meters Below Ground Level (m bgl)) | From 1.3 To 9.4 | | (b)Range of Water Table Post-Monsoon Season (Meters Below Ground Level (m bgl)) | From 0.84 To 4.47 | | (c)Whether Ground Water Intersection will be there ? | No | |
|
| 15. Details of Water Requirement (During Operation) |
|---|
| S. No. | Source | Source Other | Required Quantity (Kilolitre per Day (Kld)) | Distance from Source | Copy of Permission from Competent Authority | Mode of Transport | Other Mode of Transport | Method of Water Withdrawal | Other Method of Water Withdrawal | Letter No. | Date of Issue | Permitted Quantity |
|---|
| (1.) | Surface | | 890 | 2.5 | Copy of Permission Letter | Pipeline | | Others | river | 00 | 08 Jan 2019 | 00 |
|
|
| 15.1. | | (a)Whether Desalination is proposed | No | |
|
| 16. Waste Water Management(During Operation) |
|---|
| S. No. | Type/Source | Quantity of Waste Water Generated (Kilolitre per Day) | Treatment Capacity (Kilolitre per Day) | Treatment Method | Mode of Disposal | Other Mode of Disposal | Quantity of Treated Water Used in Recycling/Reuse (Kilolitre per Day) | Quantity of Discharged Water (Kilolitre per Day) |
|---|
| (1.) | Industrial Projects - 2 | 00 | 00 | Multiple Effect Evaporator & ETP | Reuse within the Plant & Recycling,Green Belt Renewal Plant | | 00 | |
|
|
| 16.1. | | (a)Total Waste Water Generation (Kilolitre per Day) | 0 | | (b)Total Discharged Water (Kilolitre per Day) | 0 | | (c)Total Reused Water (Kilolitre per Day) | 0 | |
|
| 17. Solid Waste Generation/Management |
|---|
| S. No. | Name of Waste | Item | Other Item | Quantity per Annum | Unit | Distance from Site(KM) | Mode of Transport | Other Mode of Transport | Mode of Disposal | Other Mode of Disposal |
|---|
| (1.) | boiler Ah | Bottom Ash | | 15 | Tons | 00 | Conveyor Belt | | Others | brick manufacturing | | (2.) | Sludge | Others | MEE | 27 | Kilolitre | 00 | Conveyor Belt | | Others | burn in the boiler |
|
|
|
| 18.1. Air Quality Impact Prediction |
|---|
| S. No. | Criteria Pollutants | Other Criteria Pollutants | Unit | Baseline Concentration | Distance GLC | Incremental Concentration | Total GLC | Prescribed Standard |
|---|
| (1.) | SO2 | | Microgram per Meter Cube | 18.7 | 1.3 | 3.5 | 22.2 | 80 | | (2.) | NOx | | Microgram per Meter Cube | 00 | 00 | 00 | 00 | 00 | | (3.) | PM10 | | Microgram per Meter Cube | 78.9 | 6.6 | 8 | 86.9 | 100 | | (4.) | PM2.5 | | Microgram per Meter Cube | 00 | 00 | 00 | 00 | 00 |
|
|
| 18.2. Stack Details |
|---|
| S. No. | Source | Fuel | Stack Height(m) | Stack Diameter(m) | Pollutants | Other Pollutants | Emission (GLS) |
|---|
| (1.) | Stack | rice husk | 36 | 1.2 | SO2 | | 11.7 |
|
|
| 19. | | Power Requirement: | | (a)Quantity (Kilo Volt Amps (kVA)) | 4000 | | (b)Source | its own co-generation power plant of capacity2* 3 | | (c)Uploaded Copy of Agreement | Copy of Agreement | | (d)Standby Arrangement (Details of DG Sets) | 500 | | (e)Stack Height (in m) | 30 | |
|
| 20. | | Land Ownership Pattern: | | (a)Forest Land (ha.) | 00 | | (b)Private Land (ha.) | 37.2 | | (c)Government Land (ha.) | 00 | | (d)Revenue Land (ha.) | 00 | | (e)Other Land (ha.) | 00 | | Total Land (ha.) | 37.2 | |
|
| 21. | | Present Land Use Breakup of the Study Area in Ha: | | (a)Agriculture Area (ha.) | 10779 | | (b)Waste/Barren Land (ha.) | 00 | | (c)Grazing/ Community Land (ha.) | 10138 | | (d)Surface Water Bodies (ha.) | 1084 | | (e)Settlements (ha.) | 1228 | | (f)Industrial (ha.) | 00 | | (g)Forest (ha.) | 469 | | (h)Mangroves (ha.) | 00 | | (i)Marine Area (ha.) | 00 | | (j)Others (ha.) : sandy/fallow land | 9228 | | Total (ha.) | 32926 | |
|
| 22. Land requirement for various activities |
|---|
| S. No. | Description of Activity / Facility / Plant / Others | Others | Land Requirement (ha.) | Remarks |
|---|
| (1.) | Green belt | | 9.71 | | | (2.) | Main Plant | | 5.56 | | | (3.) | Others | paved area/open are | 12.13 | |
|
|
|
| 23. | | Ecological and Environmental Sensitivity (Within 10 Km):- WLS-Wild Life Sanctuaries; NPA-Notified Protected Area; ESAs-Eco Sensitive Areas; ESZs-Eco Sensitive Zones : | |
|
| 23.1. Details of Ecological Sensitivity : |
|---|
| S. No. | Details of Ecological Sensitivity | Name | Distance from the Project (Km) | Remarks |
|---|
| (1.) | WLS | NA | 00 | 00 | | (2.) | NPA | na | 00 | 00 | | (3.) | Corridors | NA | 00 | 00 | | (4.) | Critically Polluted Area | NA | 00 | 00 | | (5.) | ESAs | NA | 00 | 00 | | (6.) | Wildlife Corridors | NA | 00 | 00 | | (7.) | ESZs | NA | 00 | 00 |
|
| 23.2. Details of Environmental Sensitivity : |
|---|
| S. No. | Details of Environmental Sensitivity | Other Details of Environmental Sensitivity | Name | Distance from the Project (Km) | Remarks |
|---|
| (1.) | Defence Installations | | NA | 00 | 00 | | (2.) | Archaeological Sites | | NA | 00 | 00 | | (3.) | Forest | | Near mathura | 0.3 | RF |
|
|
| 23.3. | | (a)Whether Noc / Permission from the competent authority is required? | No | | (b)Whether NBWL recommendation is required? | No | |
|
| 24. | | Forest Land: | | Whether any Forest Land involved? | No | |
|
| 25. | | Tree Cutting: | | (a)No. of Trees Cut for the Project (if Forest Land not Involved) | 00 | | (b)Details of Tree Cutting and Planting of Trees | Not Applicable | |
|
| 26. | | Land Acquisition Status: | | (a)Acquired Land(Ha) | 37.2 | | (b)Land yet to be acquired(Ha) | 00 | | (c)Status of Land acquisition if not acquired | 00 | |
|
| 27. | | Rehabilitation and Resettlement (R&R): | | (a)No. of Villages | 00 | | (b)No. of Households | 00 | | (c)No. of PDFs (Project Displaced Families) | 00 | | (d)No. of PAFs (Project Affected Families) | 00 | | (e)Funds Allocated for R&R(in INR) (in Lacs) | 00 | | (f)Status of R&R | Completed | |
|
| 28. | | Details of Presence of Schedule-I Species: | | (a)Whether there is Presence of Schedule-I Species ? | Yes | | (i)Details of Schedule-I Species | sloth bear, leopard, Indian Python, Indian Grey Hornbill, Indian peafowl | | (b)Whether conservation plan for Schedule-I Species has been prepared ? | No | | (c)Whether conservation plan for Schedule-I Species has been approved by competent authority ? | No | |
|
| 29. | | Details of Presence of Water Bodies in Core Area: | | (a)Whether there is Presence of Water Bodies in Core Area ? | No | | (b)Whether there is Diversion Required ? | No | | (c)Whether permission has been obtained from competent authority ? | No | |
|
| 30. | | Details of Presence of Water Bodies in Buffer Area: | | (a)Whether there is Presence of Water Bodies in Buffer Area ? | Yes | | (i)Details of Water Bodies in Buffer Area | hatti nadi | | (ii)Direction of Water Bodies in Buffer Area | East | | (iii)Distance of Water Bodies in Buffer Area | 2.5 | |
|
| 31. | | Manpower Requirement: | | (a)Permanent Employment-During Construction | 35 | | (b)Permanent Employment-During Operation | 100 | | (c)Temporary Employment- During Construction | 15 | | (d)Temporary Employment- During Operation | 50 | | (e)No. of working days | 330 | | (f)Total Manpower | 200 | |
|
| 32. | | Green Belt in Ha: | | (a)Total Area of Green Belt | 9.71 | | (b)Percentage of Total Project Area | 26.10 | | (c)No. of Plants to be Planted | 12000 | | (d)Funds Allocated for Plantation | 2000000 | | (e)Uploaded Green Belt plan | Copy of Green Belt Plan | |
|
| 33. Project Benefits |
|---|
| S. No. | Type of Project Benefits | Details of Project Benefits |
|---|
| (1.) | Financial | Proposed project shall generate the direct employment to approx. 200 peoples & much indirect employment opportunity for the local peoples. | | (2.) | Social | As the project is located in the area where there is no major industry is available and the villagers depend majorly on agriculture. This project shall provide the employment opportunity to the villagers. Total fund of Rs. 115 lakhs earmarked towards CSR and Rs.18 lakhs for CER activities | | (3.) | Environmental | Company is committed towards the environment & shall spend approx. The company shall spend approx. Rs. 4.55 crore of rupees towards the EMP budget also approx. Rs 2.05 crore rupees shall be spent as the recurring cost to ensure the effective working |
|
|
| 34. CRZ Specific Details : Not Applicable |
| 35. Sector Specific Details For Industrial Projects - 3 |
|
|
| 36. | | Details of Court Cases: | | (a)Whether there is any Court Cases pending against the project and/or land in which the project is proposed to be set up ? | No | |
|
| 37. | | Details of Direction Issued under Environment (Protection) Act / Air (Prevention & Control of Pollution)) Act / Water (Prevention & Control of Pollution) Act: | | (a)Whether any Direction issued under EPA Act/Air Act/Water Act ? | No | |
|
| 38. | | Details of EIA Consultant: | | (a)Have you hired Consultant for preparing document? | Yes | | (i)Accreditation No. | QCI/NABET/ENV/ACO/17/ 0279 | | (ii)Name of the EIA Consultant | Vardan Environet | | (iii)Address | D-142, Ground Floor, Sushant Lok-III, Golf Course Ext. Road, Sector-57, Gurugram, Haryana- 122002 | | (iv)Mobile No. | 9953147268 | | (v)Landline No. | 0124429103 | | (vi)Email Id | vardanenviro165@gmail.com | | (vii)Category of Accreditation | A | | (viii)Sector of Accreditation | Industrial Projects - 3 | | (ix)Validity of Accreditation | 09 Nov 2019 | | (x)Uploaded Certificate of Accreditation certified by QCI/NABET | Copy of Certificate of Accreditation | |
|
|
| Essential Detail Sought: |
|---|
| Sno. | EDS Letter | Remarks | Date of EDS |
|---|
| 1. | NA | Proposal has been submitted after expiry of validity of the ToR on 23/1/2018 (3 years validity from the date of issue), which is not acceptable as per the extant norms/guidelines. | 16 Jan 2019 | | 2. | NA | The correction have been made as per the instruction received | 18 Jan 2019 | | 3. | NA | Please submit legible copy pf the public hearing proceedings dated 1/11/2018. Also, please submit proposal seeking permission from the concerned regulatory authority for surface water requirement of 890 cum/day. | 22 Jan 2019 | | 4. | NA | The correction have been made as per the instruction received | 05 Feb 2019 | | 5. | NA | - As per the public hearing proceedings, it is revealed that more than 90% locals/public have opposed the project.
- Still no proposal submitted to meet the water requirement of 890 cum/day for the proposed distillery.
- Present status of request dated 7/10/2015 to the State Govt seeking permission for surface water withdrawal. | 09 Feb 2019 | | 6. | NA | The correction have been made as per the instruction received | 26 Feb 2019 | | 7. | NA | Please refer our earlier observations dated 9/2/2019 and your response thereto. There being conflicting statements/versions and no specific reply, it is requested that the matter may be discussed with us in the Ministry to arrive at a logical conclusion. | 03 Mar 2019 | | 8. | NA | The correction have been made as per the instruction received | 30 Apr 2019 |
|
| Additional Detail Sought: |
|---|
| Sno. | ADS Letter | Remarks | Date of ADS |
|---|
| 1. | NA | |
|